Intelligence

Analysis

FCS 3.1: Keep Original Acquisitions Separate from Derived Files

The historical FCS 3.1 paper distinguishes original and altered data. A practical review should preserve the acquisition file and make every derivative traceable.

An exported FCS file may be a derivative

A familiar file extension does not explain what happened to the events inside it. A copied file may contain changed metadata, computed parameters or a selected subset. A review should establish which file represents acquisition and which represents a later processing step.

What FCS 3.1 contributes

The FCS 3.1 publication describes optional originality and last-modification keywords to distinguish original data from altered copies, including metadata-only changes. It recommends retaining the untouched original and explains that the mechanism does not replace additional originality-certification arrangements.

This article discusses that historical specification paper. It does not assert which optional fields a current instrument or software version writes, or replace the normative specification with an implementation guide.

Original CFCM conceptual checklist: Preserve the original; Describe the derivative; Trace the relationship. No patient data or reproduced source figure.
Original CFCM conceptual diagram. Educational synthesis; not clinical validation.

Give every derivative a stated purpose

For a local educational exercise, start with a frozen acquisition file and create a processing record before making an export. State why the derivative is needed, which operation should change it and which information should remain intact. Retain the input and output identities together.

Inspect the resulting file rather than inferring its content from the export dialogue. A successful export message establishes completion of an operation; it does not by itself establish that all metadata, events or relationships were preserved as intended.

Review the chain in both directions

Choose a reported result and ask which file produced it. Then choose an acquisition file and ask which derivatives were made from it. If either question cannot be answered without guessing, the provenance record needs improvement.

Define how accidental overwriting, ambiguous filenames and missing source files should be handled. Keep audit records under the controls appropriate to the intended use. These CFCM questions are proposed verification steps, not a demonstration of regulatory compliance or an experiment on any software package. An originality keyword can be useful evidence while remaining only one part of the complete record.

Daily Learning Pill

A derivative is useful when its relationship to the original remains visible. Preserve both the data and the explanation of the change.

Explore resources and Academy. Original ChatGPT/Codex educational analysis; not independent scientific review or clinical validation.