Intelligence

Analysis

B-ALL MRD: colour count and event count changed together

An institutional comparison of five- and ten-colour flow in B-ALL illustrates why a lower observed MRD value cannot isolate the contribution of panel breadth.

CFCM Technical Review. DOI 10.7759/cureus.101730.

Standfirst: An institutional comparison of five- and ten-colour flow in B-ALL illustrates why a lower observed MRD value cannot isolate the contribution of panel breadth.

Different groups and different acquisitions

Narayanan and colleagues reported 172 paired baseline and post-induction evaluations. Post-induction testing used the five-colour platform in 51 cases and the ten-colour platform in 121. The median acquisition was 500,000 versus 2.25 million events. The platform groups are separate cohorts, so the difference in acquired events and the extra markers cannot be disentangled by comparing their positivity rates.

B-ALL MRD: colour count and event count changed together (panel 1)
Original CFCM graphic based on Narayanan et al., Cureus, DOI 10.7759/cureus.101730. Five colours: 500,000 events. Ten colours: 2.25 million events.

Positivity and the lowest observed value

Flow identified MRD in 12 of 51 five-colour cases and 26 of 121 ten-colour cases. The lowest reported positive values were 0.015% and 0.012%, respectively. These observed minima depend on the specimens and acquisition depth. The study defined a positive cluster by at least 20 events with concordant aberrancies and used 40 clustered events for quantification.

Phenotypic shifts need a redundant panel

Two MRD-positive cases detected on the ten-colour platform lacked both CD10 and CD34. That observation illustrates the value of recording several aberrancies at diagnosis and checking them after induction. It does not tell us whether the same specimens would have been missed by the five-colour assay.

Daily Learning Pill

Report the number of evaluable events and the diagnostic phenotype alongside the panel size.

Read the original article.